Guides

That's NOT My Mom Mom's Shopping List Guide

Store chapter routing, Day 1–3 foods, quiet pickups, and the ALL FOUND transition.

Last updated:

Chapter 1 of That’s NOT My Mom drops you in a grocery store with Mom’s shopping list as your only scoreboard. Every item you grab is progress. Every loud footstep is a chance for the Mimic to rewrite your day. This page is the deep dive for the Store chapter list: what to collect each day, how to route aisles, how to pick items up quietly, and what happens when ALL FOUND finally flashes.

Pair this with getting started if you are brand new, survive the Mimic for sound control, and the chapter walkthrough when you want Store tips beside Water Park, Airport, and Department Store notes.

How the shopping list works

At the start of each Store day you receive a list of foods. You must collect every item on that list. Partial progress does not finish the day. The UI tracks what remains, so check it after each pickup instead of guessing. In co-op, one player should own the list callouts so three people are not sprinting toward the same cereal box.

Items sit on shelves, endcaps, and cold cases. Approaching and collecting still makes noise if you run up, slam into carts, or spam jump. Walk the last few steps into each pickup. If the Mimic is patrolling that aisle, skip to a safe item and return later—the list does not require a fixed order, only completion.

Day 1 foods

Day 1 keeps the list short so you learn the floor plan: Cereal, Cupcakes, and Watermelon. Route cereal and cupcakes along dry-goods aisles first, then swing to produce or the cold area for watermelon. Three stops means you can rehearse walk speed, hide under a table once, and still finish with time for the whistle check.

Treat Day 1 as a stealth tutorial. Do not farm chaos. Clear the three items, wait for ALL FOUND, then practice identifying the real Mom. That habit transfers to longer days.

Day 2 foods

Day 2 expands to Apple, Bread, Ice Cream, Carrots, and Ketchup. Mix produce (apple, carrots), bakery (bread), condiments (ketchup), and frozen (ice cream). A clean loop is produce first, mid-store dry goods next, freezer last so you are not carrying a long path through the loudest traffic after the Mimic has woken up.

Ice cream and other freezer grabs often sit in tighter spaces. Enter walking, collect, exit the same way you came if the far end is a dead end. Ketchup and bread are easy to overshoot—confirm the label before you commit so you do not waste a noisy second trip.

Day 3 foods and extras

Day 3 is the Store stress test: Apple, Frozen Pizza, Cereal, Cookies, Chicken, Chips, and Ice Cream. That is seven foods plus environmental pressure. Cobwebs can slow or obscure routes—plan around them instead of charging through while the sound meter climbs. The Tall Watcher also appears: look at it to freeze it, like a Weeping Angel rule. If you look away while close, it can advance. Assign one teammate to hold gaze while others collect nearby items, then rotate.

Because the list is long, split the store into zones. Player A takes cereal, cookies, chips. Player B takes apple and chicken. Player C takes frozen pizza and ice cream. Meeting back near a known hide table beats everyone weaving the same aisle.

Aisle routing principles

Plan a loop, not a star. Star routing (base to item to base) multiplies footsteps. A loop that hits neighboring shelves in one pass cuts distance and noise. Start on the edge of the store closest to your first cluster, sweep inward, and finish near a hide spot so you are already covered if ALL FOUND triggers a louder Mimic response.

Avoid shopping carts and physics clutter when possible; knocking objects creates sound spikes. If a cart blocks an aisle, walk around rather than shoving it. Corner mirrors and open sightlines help you spot the Mimic before you enter—pause at aisle mouths, look, then commit.

Quiet pickup technique

  1. Walk the approach; never sprint the last tile.
  2. Stop moving the moment the pickup prompts.
  3. After the item registers, walk away—do not celebratory jump.
  4. Recheck the list before the next sprint of decisions.
  5. If the sound meter rose, hide first, shop second.

These five steps sound obvious until Day 3 panic sets in. Rehearse them on Day 1 so muscle memory holds when cobwebs and the Tall Watcher stack stress.

After ALL FOUND

When every list item is collected, ALL FOUND (or the equivalent clear banner) signals that shopping is done—not that you won. The end-of-day sequence begins: two whistles, one real Mom, one Mimic. Do not run toward the first parental figure you see. Reset your sound, move to a neutral vantage point, and use the identity checks from find the real Mom.

In co-op, freeze shopping chatter and switch to whistle callouts. The player with the clearest audio should declare which figure is safe. Everyone else holds position until that call. Rushing as a group into the impostor ends five runs at once.

Common Store mistakes

  • Grabbing Day 2 or Day 3 muscle memory on Day 1 and wasting time at empty shelves.
  • Leaving ice cream for last while the Mimic camps the freezer corridor.
  • Ignoring the Tall Watcher gaze rule on Day 3.
  • Celebrating ALL FOUND with a sprint that pulls the Mimic into the whistle arena.
  • Forgetting revive duty when a teammate downs mid-aisle.

Practice plan

Run Day 1 until you can clear Cereal, Cupcakes, and Watermelon without sprinting. Then Day 2 with a planned produce-to-freezer loop. Then Day 3 with role splits and a Watcher spotter. After each clear, deliberately practice the whistle identification instead of quitting to lobby. When Store feels stable, move on with the chapter walkthrough and keep using survive the Mimic whenever sound discipline slips.

Master the shopping list and the Store stops feeling like a maze. It becomes a quiet circuit you control—right up until the whistles ask who Mom really is.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers for Mimic hunts, chapters, and co-op.

What foods are on Day 1 of the Store chapter?

Day 1 requires Cereal, Cupcakes, and Watermelon. Use it to learn walk speed, aisle loops, and the whistle ending before longer lists.

What is on the Day 2 and Day 3 shopping lists?

Day 2: Apple, Bread, Ice Cream, Carrots, and Ketchup. Day 3: Apple, Frozen Pizza, Cereal, Cookies, Chicken, Chips, and Ice Cream, plus cobwebs and the Tall Watcher.

Do I need to collect items in a specific order?

No. Any order works. Choose a quiet loop that clusters nearby shelves and finish near a hide spot before the ALL FOUND transition.

What should I do when ALL FOUND appears?

Stop shopping, control your sound, and prepare for the dual-whistle Mom check. Reaching the Mimic impostor still fails the day.

How do cobwebs and the Tall Watcher change Day 3?

Cobwebs slow routing—path around them. The Tall Watcher freezes while you look at it; assign a spotter in co-op so collectors can move safely.